Both prospects had a good showing with the Cardinals and now that Kyle Lohse is on the free agent market, one of them is expected to take his spot in the rotation. Both could have good fantasy value next year and are worthy of a late round flier because of their upside.


The case for Shelby Miller
Miller came into the season as St. Louis’ number one prospect and for good reason. He was select 19th overall in the 2009 major league baseball draft out of Brownwood High School. There was no question he had the kind of upside you look for in the first round, a potential ace for St. Louis.


Lets take you through his minor league numbers, not including 2009 because he only pitched in two games that season.

  • 2010 (A): 7-5, 104 innings pitched, 140 K, 3.62 ERA, 1.246 WHIP.
  • 2011 (A+, AA): 11-6, 139.2 IP, 170 K, 2.77 ERA, 1.181 WHIP.
  • 2012 (AAA): 11-10, 136.2 IP, 160 K, 4.74 ERA, 1.376 WHIP.


As you can see, Miller handled the low levels of the minor leagues just fine and that’s expected with a top prospect. Once he arrived at Triple-A, he struggled. That’s concerning to me for such a highly regarded arm, who has now seen Oscar Taveras pass him as the Cardinals top prospect. 
He did pitch in the Pacific Coast League, which is one of the more hitter friendly leagues. Miller’s command needs to improve if he wants to be in the Cardinals rotation.


When Miller came up to the majors, he was much better so you have to consider that as well. In his only start of the season, Miller pitched six innings, allowing just one hit to the Cincinnati Reds in St. Louis.


The case for Trevor Rosenthal
Rosenthal was not a known commodity by many to start the season, but that would change when he came up in July and was an important part of the Cardinals bullpen. Like Miller, he was selected in the 2009 draft, but not until the 21st round. When it comes to prospects, they make their own future and Rosenthal looks like he could be a big part of the Cardinals. He was originally a shortstop, but converted to a pitcher and could throw in the mid 90’s during his years in high school.


Listed below are Rosenthal’s minor league numbers.


  • 2009 (Rk): 4-1, 24 IP, 26 K, 4.88 ERA, 1.458 WHIP.
  • 2010 (Rk): 3-0, 32 IP, 30 K, 2.25 ERA, 0.938 WHIP.
  • 2011 (A): 7-7, 120 IP, 133 K, 4.11 ERA, 1.247 WHIP.
  • 2012 (AA, AAA): 8-6, 109 IP, 104 K, 2.97 ERA, 1.101 WHIP.


While Rosenthal’s numbers are not as impressive as Miller’s, in 2011 he did help lead the Quad City River Bandits to a championship in the Midwest League.


Cardinals general Manager John Mozeliak on Rosenthal: "We realized we had a talent early on, when we sent him to Johnson City. Then when he went to Quad Cities, we knew exactly what we had because he really took off there."


Rosenthal was deemed ready for the major leagues in 2010 and really impressed the Cardinals organization with his velocity and assortment of quality pitches. He did this once again in 2011 spring training, but St. Louis decided it was best to let him continue to work in the minor leagues.


Rosenthal’s numbers with St. Louis during the regular season (19 games): 0-2, 22.2 IP, 25 K, 2.78 ERA, 0.93 WHIP


During the Cardinals playoff run, Rosenthal struck out 15 opposing batters in just 8.2 innings pitched.


During the off-season, Rosenthal is going to stay in St. Louis and train with Cardinals veteran Chris Carpenter.


Both are very intriguing talents, but purely for next year I’m going to give the edge to Rosenthal. He’s just more polished at this point in his career than Miller. Long term, these two guys could be fixtures at the top of the Cardinals rotation.


Mac can be found on the forums as dmvincent and you can also follow him on Twitter @MacVincent1

More by Mac:

Write comment
Comments (3)add comment

gregory churchill said:

gregory churchill
both i think the cardinal rotation will make room for both miller and rosenthal, 2013. i think each will get about 130-150 MLB innings. i think they will both do very well.

garcia's shoulder troubles aren't going away. best case, i think he will need downtime throughout the season.

westbrook is a backend innings eater w/o upside.

lynn is living well off his plus plus FB's. however, despite his ability to throw three different off-speed pitches, none of them were effective in 2012. with improved control of his off-speed stuff, he is a solid choice in the rotation, ahead of both westbrook and garcia. however, if he continues to have location issues, the struggles he endured in the 2H of 2012 may require him to move back into the bullpen for long periods. i think he will make the required improvements, and again be a winner for the cardinals. but he DOES need to improve.

January 31, 2013
Votes: +0

Mac Vincent said:

Mac Vincent
... John, thanks for reading.

I see the Cardinals rotation looking something like this next year. Lynn is definitely a lock as far as I'm concerned.

1. Wainwright
2. Carpenter
3. Lynn
4. Westbrook
5. One of Miller, Garcia or Rosenthal

I hope that helps.
November 22, 2012
Votes: +0

John said:

Popfly What about Lance Lynn? He enters into the Cardinals' rotation equation. It just hasn't been guaranteed from what I've read. Do you know more and can you expand on this?
November 21, 2012 | url
Votes: +0
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.